Proposal for scientific comparison of bicycle hill-climbing performance

Jim Parker, MD, Cruzbike, Inc.
Many Cruzbike owners have made the observation that they climb faster on a Cruzbike vs. other rear wheel drive (RWD) recumbent bicycles. Clearly, there are complex biomechanics involving the upper and lower body when hill climbing on a regular road bike  (watch this video of Lance Armstrong climbing for an example). The Cruzbike pivoting-boom front wheel drive (PB-FWD) bicycle has some obvious similarities to the road bike when hill climbing: both make use of rhythmic pulling on the handlebars to angle/lean a compact tetrahedral drivetrain, and both take a slightly sinusoidal wheel path during maximum hill-climbing effort.  Based on these observations and testimonials from Cruzbike cyclists, we have reason to believe that the Cruzbike PB-FWD design climbs faster than a standard RWD recumbent. Now let’s look at what would be required to prove this hypothesis scientifically.
First, the research would need to be conducted by an independent researcher. Some people have called for Cruzbike, Inc., to conduct the research. However, if we did, and the hypothesis was confirmed, many people would consider the results biased, and disregard them. Secondly, a good research protocol needs to control for many variables, and have enough data points to have statistical power.  In short, a scientific, randomized, controlled study would require considerable planning and proper execution to have merit. However, the effort may be worthwhile.  Recumbent bicycles are acknowledged to offer many advantages over the standard safety bike, but they have a reputation for being slow when climbing hills. If it could be proven that the PB-FWD recumbent design climbed significantly faster than other recumbent designs, it could greatly widen the acceptance and popularity of recumbent bicycles.
Here is a suggested proposal for such a research project that attempts to control for all the important variables, including physical fitness, age, body weight, bicycle weight, and adaptation to the unique pedaling characteristics of each format. Other protocols may be equally or more efficient at testing the hypothesis.
________________________________________
Proposed Method:
Recruit a number of active adult cyclists from the same geographic area with no recumbent riding experience.  They number would be determined by the investigator to provide the needed statistical power to prove or disprove the hypothesis. The cyclists could be volunteers or paid a small fee for participating.  Basic demographic information of the riders would be collected (age, weight, height, gender, etc.) At the initial meeting of the recruited cyclists, they would each perform a time trial on their regular DF bike climbing up a reference hill with approximately a 5 to 10% grade and 1000 meter length.  Heart rate would be monitored. Next, randomly assign each cyclist to one of the test groups (i.e. PB-FWD or RWD recumbent).
Each cyclist would receive a 30 minute introduction to the bike, and would agree to train on the bike 6 to 10 hours per week for 12 weeks, keeping a log of their training. A research affiliate would check in by telephone or email weekly to make sure cyclists were putting in the required training.
At the end of the first six weeks, the cyclists would re-convene with their assigned recumbent bicycle and repeat the time trial, climbing the same hill, again monitoring heart rate.  The bikes would have approximately the same gear ratios and similar tire tread and air pressure. The weight of the bicycles would be equalized by adding weight to the lighter bicycles. Training would continue for another six weeks and the time trials would be repeated at 12 weeks, concluding the study. Standard statistical analysis would determine if there was a significant difference in climbing speed between the two test groups.
Key points here are 1) the randomization of the participants so that both groups would have the same probability of having participants of equal age, fitness, level, body weight, etc.; 2) by having participants with no recumbent experience, there will be no advantage from a longer adaptation period; 3) by equalizing bicycle weight, tires, and gearing, the only variable left is the actual bicycle drive system, and 4) by having one long hill-climb as the test course, speeds will be low and advantages from aerodynamic differences will be minimized. High-tech monitoring of power output and/or oxygen consumption is not needed to test the hypothesis and has been intentionally omitted to reduce the cost and complexity of the study.
Sponsorship of this research by more than one recumbent manufacturer is important to avoid the appearance of bias. If an independent University-based researcher would like to lead such a research project, Cruzbike, Inc., will cooperate and provide up to $10,000 in funds or bicycles if at least one other recumbent bicycle manufacturer does the same.
------------------------------------------------
Any interested investigator or recumbent manufacturer should contact me at parker@cruzbike.com.

Kenneth Jessett's picture

Interesting posit, however I

Interesting posit, however I doubt very much if the results would persuade more cyclists to take up recumbents or those that do ride recumbents to buy another machine albeit it a FWD. So, you might spend time and money proving a point which in reality would have little bearing on the recumbent market. Just my twopence worth. Smile

banerjek's picture

The proposed study strikes me

The proposed study strikes me as a bit complicated to execute, and I think power should be part of the equation if possible.

Seems like it would be easier to just get riders to switch a PT wheel between two bikes that they ride everywhere for a few months and log all the data on Strava (with a different account for each bike) or some other place. You'll get thousands of miles per rider fast and if there is any benefit, it will show up.

If you're looking for volunteers for a hill climbing study, count me in. My daily commute http://ridewithgps.com/routes/1524564 has over a thousand feet of climbing in just a few miles and I live near one of your dealers. I have other 'bents which I take in the hills as well as a couple DF's, so I could generate some decent hill climbing data pretty fast.

I recently took one of the Cruzbikes for a short spin.  As I was unexperienced with its handling characteristics, my sprints weren't quite working the way I wanted, but I had a blast once I got it up to speed. The bike is outrageously comfortable -- best I've ever tried (and I've been on a lot of bikes). I would look forward to an opportunity to become more acquainted with the Cruzebike.

imtheBMAXboss's picture

i just knew that Lance

i just knew that Lance Armstrong is now using a Cruzbike...I would like to have one here

buy twitter favorites    

badoky's picture

bicycle hill climbing is not

bicycle hill climbing is not easy,.  it needs physical endurance and you must be psychologically/mentally positive that you can surpass it,. one technique also is u need to ha you own phasing hitting the pedal,.. 
purchase soundcloud plays

KuroSou19's picture

I agree with you badoky, I

I agree with you badoky, I think the most difficult part in cycling is the hill climbing because it is going upwards and if it is a tournament the more the cyclist or should I say a specific cyclist called the "Climber" would want to win the "King of the Mountains" title especially in a race like the "Tour de France".
purchase facebook post likes
zell's picture

What weight exactly can use

What weight exactly can use the cruzbike? For the record I love your product.increase soundcloud followers

miakana's picture

A fascinating bicycle. I

A fascinating bicycle. I wanna have one of it!!  if you have a raffle please pick me.. buy reverbnation plays

charing's picture

i just stop and watch this

i just stop and watch this website and i found out that this is very interesting. Always wanted to have one. Thank you for sharing.
free youtube views

metchie's picture

This is a great article,

This is a great article, Thank you for sharing 
your information about this topic. I really appreciate this a lot
. Have a great day !
buy vine packages

kram's picture

Good post for this

Good post for this article.Really interesting.I wanna try a cruzbike.Thank you for posting.
buy soundcloud downloads

Shiro21's picture

This a great article that you

This a great article that you posted because it is very inspiring.I love to watch someone hill-climbing because it is very difficult and challenging.
get instagram services

Kevinosbern's picture

Hello World!!

Hello World!!

jhonSnider01's picture

get datpiff downloads I

get datpiff downloads I  ?discovered a great deal of helpful things for monetization from here. Cheers. A extremely helpful and one-of-a-kind material offered which is really appreciable, Thanks a great deal for discussing such a terrific
short article.

kyunkyun20's picture

Really great post, thank you

Really great post, thank you for sharing this knowledge.Excellently written article.
<a href="http://getmysocial.org/buy-datpiff-plays/">get datpiff plays</a>

kiko321's picture

It such a good and you gave

It such a good and you gave us great thoughts!
get instagram serviceshttp://www.boostmyownlikes.org

temari74's picture

Great comparison! now I know

Great comparison! now I know the difference Smile

get instagram services

Kevinosbern's picture

I did see the end results of

I did see the end results of this scientific experiment, but I was still not convinced about the effectiveness of cruzbikes in hill climbing. The riding position was the main issue that was pointed out by most of the bikers.

Beverly Diamonds Ripoff Report
 

Fritz14's picture

Thanks for posting. Still a

Thanks for posting. Still a great comparison.

purchase soundcloud downloads

Fritz14's picture

Thanks for this informative

Thanks for this informative post.

increase soundcloud comments

jesonko's picture

I really appreciate this

I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. I assure this would be beneficial for most of the people. Looking forward to read more of your post and updates in the future. buy soundcloud downloads

iamrobin's picture

Cool! Very informative

Cool!
Very informative post
thanks for sharing this to us

increase soundcloud services

iamclara's picture

Hey guys ! check this out

Hey guys ! check this out --> ?<a href="http://socialsoundcloud.org/buy-soundcloud-downloads/">buy soundcloud downloads</a>

ibyaaang1009's picture

the article is very

the article is very informative! thanks for sharing this to us. just keep on posting

get instagram services

pythons18's picture

Great information Very

Great information
Very resourceful

check this: ?<a href="http://socialsoundcloud.org/">increase soundcloud services</a>

renuka's picture

I simply want to tell you

I simply want to tell you that I am new to weblog and definitely liked this blog site. I have been meaning to write something like this on my website and you have given me an idea.
University in Haryana

laarns's picture

what a great proposal! I love

what a great proposal! I love it! 
<a href="http://socialsoundcloud.org/">increase soundcloud services</a>
Ramz Torres's picture

Thank you for posting! Will

Thank you for posting! Will be expecting more from you and keep it up. Smile

buy soundcloud followers

makiem's picture

this article is

this article is awesome.. 
cycling is totally fun.. Smile

<a href="http://socialsoundcloud.org/">increase soundcloud services</a>
Smile

iamchae's picture

Hey Guys ! Thanks for this

Hey Guys ! Thanks for this post ! Very useful and informative. Looking forward for more of your article ! God bless !

<a href="http://socialexperience.org/buy-twitter-favorites/">get twitter favorites</a>

iamchae's picture

Hey Guys ! Thanks for this

Hey Guys ! Thanks for this post ! Very useful and informative. Looking forward for more of your article ! God bless !

<a href="http://socialexperience.org/buy-twitter-favorites/">gain Twitter favorites</a>